Post a reply

Options
Add an Attachment

If you do not want to add an Attachment to your Post, please leave the Fields blank.

(maximum 10 MB; please compress large files; only common media, archive, text and programming file formats are allowed)

Options

Topic review

martin

tyrel wrote:

For the record, commercial SFTP server implementations seem to be holding back on ACLs and other SFTP features because there's no client support. There seems to be a chicken-or-the-egg thing going on here and it has been for a couple years at least. Someone needs to take the first leap, and my guess is it's not going to be the commercial vendors.

I'm aware of that. But it is hard to implement anything when I do not have a server to test it against. While most server vendors have client application as well, so they can test it.
tyrel

For the record, commercial SFTP server implementations seem to be holding back on ACLs and other SFTP features because there's no client support. There seems to be a chicken-or-the-egg thing going on here and it has been for a couple years at least. Someone needs to take the first leap, and my guess is it's not going to be the commercial vendors.
martin

Re: Support ACL for SFTP

This issue has been added to tracker.
Teka

Sorry for the up.

It's just a remind for you ;)
martin

Teka wrote:

Maybe I can add sftp-extension (it's a standard extension) checksum in order to help you for this post: https://winscp.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=1959 ?

I do not know how it would help with the post, but it would be definitely a nice feature to have anyway :-)
martin

Teka wrote:

Come on our forum and i'll gave you an alpha version with support acl (in theory since i can't test :oops: ) :D

Will come, once I find time for testing. Thanks!
Teka

Come on our forum and i'll gave you an alpha version with support acl (in theory since i can't test :oops: ) :D
martin

Re: Support ACL for SFTP

Teka wrote:

For the moment support full sftp protocol v5 and some extensions like (disk-usage is already supported) copy support, ... ;)

OK, I'll try to test your server :-)
Teka

Re: Support ACL for SFTP

martin wrote:

Teka wrote:

Are you interested by working together for support more features on sftp protocol ?

Sure :-) What do you plan?


For the moment support full sftp protocol v5 and some extensions like (disk-usage is already supported) copy support, ... ;)
martin

Re: Support ACL for SFTP

Teka wrote:

Are you interested by working together for support more features on sftp protocol ?

Sure :-) What do you plan?
Teka

Re: Support ACL for SFTP

martin wrote:

I do not know of any server supporting the feature. Do you?


That's a good reason :(

But I'm working on a OpenSource project (MySecureShell: https://github.com/mysecureshell/mysecureshell). ;)
And I'll implement Sftp protocol 4 and 5 (for the moment no support of acl).

Are you interested by working together for support more features on sftp protocol ?
martin

Re: Support ACL for SFTP

I do not know of any server supporting the feature. Do you?
Teka

Support ACL for SFTP

This features is planned ?

Because WinSCP support sftp protocol v5 but not (yet ?) ACL :)