Save prior versions during synchronize :: Support Forum

poojanwagh
Joined:: 2008-08-20
Posts:: 4

Save prior versions during synchronize

2008-10-13 12:14

Hi. When I synchronize to a remote server, I'd like WinSCP to save prior versions (backup copies) of files upon re-write or delete.

For example, if I start with the following files:

local (version)           remote (version)
---------------           ----------------
readme.txt (1)            readme.txt (1)

And then modify readme.txt locally:

local (version)           remote (version)
---------------           ----------------
readme.txt (2)            readme.txt (1)

Then I do a sync, I'd like two things to happen: 1) a backup copy of readme.txt is created remotely, either using a specified filename or in a separate directory; and 2) the actual sync from local to remote is performed:

Step 1:

local (version)           remote (version)
---------------           ----------------
readme.txt (2)            readme.txt (1)
                          => readme.txt.1.bak

Step 2:

local (version)           remote (version)
---------------           ----------------
readme.txt (2)            readme.txt (2)
                          readme.txt.1.bak

Reply with quote

martin◆ Site Admin
Joined:: 2002-12-10
Posts:: 41,441
Location:: Prague, Czechia

Re: Save prior versions during synchronize

2008-10-13

Have you tried remote recycle bin?

Reply with quote

poojanwagh

Re: Save prior versions during synchronize

2008-10-13 15:29

That's exactly what I need. I didn't see that in the docs. (I did look, but apparently not long enough.) Thanks! I take it I can use it with the synchronize feature?

Reply with quote

martin◆ Site Admin

Re: Save prior versions during synchronize

2008-10-15

poojanwagh wrote:

I take it I can use it with the synchronize feature?

Correct.

Reply with quote

Ricoman Guest

Rename is better than recycle

2008-11-19 20:31

The renaming scheme that was suggested is much better than the remote recycle bin in some situations.

First, remote recycle bin is only available for SFTP, but renaming files would be available for all flavors of FTP.

Second, keeping the versioned (backup) file in the same directory as the original one allows for easy comparison between all versions. (e.g. easier command to a "diff" program etc)

I feel that simple backup-file renaming is a MUST for any good FTP program, however I have only seen acceptatble implementations of it in AceFTP (which has many other problems of its own.)

Reply with quote

martin◆ Site Admin
Joined:: 2002-12-10
Posts:: 41,441
Location:: Prague, Czechia

Re: Rename is better than recycle

2008-11-21

Ricoman wrote:

First, remote recycle bin is only available for SFTP, but renaming files would be available for all flavors of FTP.

Neither of these is be possible with SCP. With FTP both is possible, it is just not implemented yet. So this is not an argument.

That does not mean I'm against this. It more people ask for that...

Reply with quote

martin◆ Site Admin

Re: Rename is better than recycle

2008-11-24

This request has been added to tracker.

Reply with quote

pinepitch
Joined:: 2019-05-09
Posts:: 1
Location:: Praha, CZ

WinSCP verzovani

2019-05-09 21:35

Dobry den,
Predevsim moc dekuji za WinSCP. Vynikajici pocin! Ale k veci: vzhledem k tomu, ze aktualne neexistuje normalne podporovany souborovy system umoznujici verzovani na urovni souboru, a tudiz verzovani je skoro vzdy reseno na aplikacni urovni pomerne drahymi systemy, dovoluji si diletantsky navrhnout upravu WinSCP navazujici na predchozi letite posty zde ve vlakne :)

Smyslem navrhu je umoznit spolupracujici skupine lidi sdilet souborove struktury na SFTP serveru (kde maji ruzni uzivatele ruzna prava na ruzne slozky resene pomoci ACL) s minimalizovanym rizikem ztraty dat v dusledku vzajemneho prepsani sdileneho souboru. Je jiste, ze navrh ma k dokonalosti hodne daleko, ale velmi spoleham na to, ze navrh vylepsite a zdokonalite a nejak vhodne zaclenite do WinSCP. Navrh odstranuje nejvetsi bolest takoveho sdileni ve stavajicim provedeni - nemoznost uzivatelskeho dohledani souboru omylem prepsaneho nebo smazaneho jinym uzivatelem. V tomto vlakne drive navrhovany remote recycle bin neni resenim, nebot predpoklada, ze k nemu budou mit pristup vsichni uzivatele, coz velmi casto neni mozne. Smyslem navrhu tedy neni zabranit cilene diverzi, ale umoznit uzivatelskou napravu chyb.

Nekde v nastaveni by pribyly nasledujici volby:
Verzovat: zaskrtavatko
Nazev slozky verzi: .Versions
Hloubka verzovani: N

Pri zapnutem verzovani:

tedy nejak takto:

Podklady.pdf ->Versions/Podklady.jindriskaplacha.2019_05_23_14_53_47.pdf

pripadne:

Podklady.pdf ->Versions/Podklady.jindriskaplacha.2019_05_23_14_53_47-1.pdf

Lze jiste velmi snadno - pouhym vypnutim verzovani ziskat potrebna prava potrebna k nejake nekale akci, ale jak jsem jiz psal, tento rezim predpoklada dobrou vuli a chrani jen pred omyly (nakonec stejne jako bezne souborove sdileni na siti LAN)

Prosim taky o svoleni kontaktovat Vas ohledne dalsich podrobnosti, ktere nechci psat na verejne forum.

Dekuji moc za Vas cas

Reply with quote

martin◆ Site Admin
Joined:: 2002-12-10
Posts:: 41,441
Location:: Prague, Czechia

Re: WinSCP verzovani

2019-05-13

pinepitch wrote:

Predevsim moc dekuji za WinSCP. Vynikajici pocin! Ale k veci: vzhledem k tomu, ze aktualne neexistuje normalne podporovany souborovy system umoznujici verzovani na urovni souboru, a tudiz verzovani je skoro vzdy reseno na aplikacni urovni pomerne drahymi systemy, dovoluji si diletantsky navrhnout upravu WinSCP navazujici na predchozi letite posty zde ve vlakne :)
...
V tomto vlakne drive navrhovany remote recycle bin neni resenim, nebot predpoklada, ze k nemu budou mit pristup vsichni uzivatele, coz velmi casto neni mozne. Smyslem navrhu tedy neni zabranit cilene diverzi, ale umoznit uzivatelskou napravu chyb.

Diky za navrh.
Ale vase reseni take vyzaduje adresar (.Versions), ke kteremu maji pristup vsichni. A na druhou stranu, neni pravda, ze musi mit vsichni uzivatele stejny "Remote recycle bin". (Samozrejme vidim, ze stavajici "Remote recycle bin" neni tak chytry, jako vas navrh/jak potrebujete)
Muj email je v mem profilu.

Reply with quote